Skip to content

Mike Penning Needs To Read This

March 30, 2014

From Sue Marsh.

 

So, on Thursday 27th March, the DWP Press Office announced that Atos were no more.
Today we are announcing we are seeking a new provider to replace Atos for the Work Capability Assessment

Let’s be very clear : This is cause for celebration. It’s reputation in absolute tatters, Atos was left with no choice but to slink off, tail between its legs to lick its wounds. They have administered a failing test badly and hundreds of thousands have suffered their incompetence.

But for nearly 3 years now we’ve been warning that this was the only possible outcome. Atos would always fall because the work capability assessments themselves are so badly designed. They were contracted to fall. They were always the scapegoat. It’s astonishing really that none of their board could see it, and as late as last year were bidding for yet more disability assessment contracts for the new PIP (personal independence payments, the replacement for DLA or disability living allowance). How do governments introduce appalling schemes designed to hurt and harm? Make sure there is a middle man, then when the inevitable collapse comes, you can deny all responsibility. 

But DWP ARE responsible and we must not let anyone forget it for a second. This is a very dangerous time for our campaigns. It is entirely possible that the DWP will simply replace Atos with Capita or G4S or Serco, the test will still be fundamentally flawed and nothing will change. We can’t let that happen. It would be unconscionable for the DWP to re-tender the WCA contract without first conducting root and branch reform of the processes that guide it.

 
Do the DWP show any signs of this? Their next tweet said
Aim is to drive up the number of WCA assessments and cut waiting times
 
So not to improve accuracy? Not to stop ludicrous decisions leading to suffering and even suicides? Not to right a wrong but to force through even more of the same!
Later in the day, they released an official statement
Here’s today’s written ministerial statement on the Work Capability Assessment
Did you spot the glaring omission? 
 
WHAT HAPPENS NOW MR PENNING??????
 
You’ve just released an official statement confirming that an existing supplier has walked away from an enormous and sensitive contract. Millions of sick and disabled people are already IN the system, waiting for assessments, appealing decisions or being reassessed.
 
WHAT HAPPENS TO THEM MR PENNING?????
 
Will assessments continue? How? Who will do them? When? People are already waiting up to a year for decisions, what happens to them??
ISN’T IT SHOCKING THAT A GOVERNMENT MINISTER SHOULD ANNOUNCE THE TERMINATION OF A CONTRACT IN THIS WAY WITHOUT REASSURING CLAIMANTS THAT ALL WILL BE WELL MR PENNING?????
 
This is continents away from a joke now.
 
We warned PIP had to be paused. 
We were ignored
In the end, they had no choice but to pause it
 
We warned the bedroom tax would cost more than it saved leading to soaring housing benefit
We were ignored. 
Now we know we were right
 
We warned that the Work Programme simply couldn’t cope with the complexities of sick and disabled people
We were ignored
Less than 1% have sustained work for more than 6 months
 
We warned that Atos simply couldn’t manage the volume of ESA assessments
We were ignored
Now, reassessments have been paused and decisions are taking up to  year 
 
We warned that Atos were simply the middle man
We were ignored
Now they’ve gone, seemingly leaving nothing in their place. 
 
WHEN WILL THIS GOVERNMENT START TO LISTEN? 
HAD THEY LISTENED FROM THE START, NONE OF THIS WOULD HAVE HAPPENED
 
Finally, what if no-one wants the job??? I find it almost impossible to believe that Serco or Capita or G4S would take this on. They’ve all seen the reputation of Atos utterly decimated by the ESA contract. Possibly irredeemably. Why on EARTH would they fill the gap? They must know that unless the tests changed significantly campaigners will fight them just as determinedly – possibly more so for having absolutely no excuse – I mean, one might argue Atos didn’t know how bad things would get, how badly the tests would fail. Crapico4S know.
COULD IT BE THAT ESA IS DEAD BY DEFAULT???

 

5 Comments leave one →
  1. allan j's avatar
    allan j permalink
    March 30, 2014 4:47 pm

    if there is money on the end of it someone will take it up

    Like

    • clivegsd's avatar
      March 31, 2014 10:43 am

      Perhaps they could donate money for laptops, but only if they were targeting really gullible idiots for donations

      Like

  2. Jonathan Wilson's avatar
    March 30, 2014 5:11 pm

    Considering that in the ATOS statement they said “we will help to move our staff to the new provider to ensure a seamless transfer” or words to that effect, the writing is on the wall…

    Nothing will change, the processes, staff, and computer systems will just move from one company to another and nothing will change…

    The DWP will enforce the WCA by frigging the process to remove eligibility for ever greater numbers (by awarding lower points for more indicators), but will probably introduce more paperwork and tracking, so that results will be verifiable and will work (and be proven to work with lower number of appeals being won as the “process will not be at fault”) but more and more people will loose out…

    To take it to its logical conclusion, by setting and awarding 0 points to every indicator no one will be eligible for ESA, the C*ntservatives and the C*ntservative democrats will then congratulate themselves by eliminating (on paper at least) all the sick and disabled in a master piece of Orwellian double speak and will have the combined powers of God and Jesus as everyone is now cured.

    Que heavenly choir and the rapture :-/

    Like

  3. Barry Davies's avatar
    Barry Davies permalink
    March 30, 2014 7:40 pm

    It could be out of the frying pan as far as this episode is concerned, I see no possibility of the government ending this attack on the needy, there mantra “for hardworking people” says it all.

    Like

  4. Nick's avatar
    Nick permalink
    March 30, 2014 9:58 pm

    Serco or Capita or G4S will take it on irrespective of any bad press as these companies and those that work for them in the majority have no morels in the slightest

    the bottom line is at the end of the day is on how much profit can be made and if errors are made and people die then so be it

    we can cut and run just like ATOS if the deaths stack up in which I’m sure they will

    Like

Leave a reply to Jonathan Wilson Cancel reply