Skip to content

Catherine McKinnell MP Tackles PM On Motability Cuts

March 10, 2016

Newcastle North MP, Catherine McKinnell, has today tackled the Prime Minister about the number of disabled people losing their independence as a result of the Government’s benefit changes since 2013.

Speaking during Prime Minister’s Questions in the Commons, Catherine raised the case of her constituent, William Bradney, who has recently been told he is no longer eligible for a Motability vehicle despite a lifelong disability caused by contracting polio as an infant.

The Motability scheme helps disabled people to be independent by enabling them to exchange their mobility allowance to lease a car, scooter or powered wheelchair.  Previously, people in receipt of the highest rate of the ‘mobility component’ of Disability Living Allowance (DLA) were eligible for the Motability scheme.

However, following welfare reforms which replaced DLA with the Personal Independence Payment (PIP) in April 2013, new and existing claimants must now undergo a new assessment and figures uncovered by the BBC last month revealed that almost 14,000 people with disabilities had lost their Motability vehicles as a result.

Catherine asked the Prime Minister:

‘In 1949, aged 11 months, my constituent William Bradney was diagnosed with polio.

‘He has worked from the age of 15, and he continues to work at 67.

‘But following a clearly flawed PIP assessment, he’s set to lose his Motability car, potentially within three weeks. He says it will leave him unable to leave the house and unable to work.

‘Will the Prime Minister urgently review his case, and the cases of 14,000 disabled people who’ve lost this essential lifeline?’

And speaking after Prime Minister’s Questions, Catherine said:

‘I’m pleased the Prime Minister has agreed to look into my constituent’s case as a matter of urgency – and this really is urgent as Mr Bradney faces losing his car within the next three weeks.

‘But the Government’s changes have hit many thousands of disabled people across the country and there’s a cruel irony in renaming this benefit ‘Personal Independence Payment’ when it’s actually resulted in thousands of people not being able work, or even leave their house, as a result of their Motability lifeline being taken away.

‘It’s just outrageous that Mr Bradney, who values his independence and is still working at the age of 67, now faces losing all of this a result of what is clearly a flawed PIP assessment process.

‘And, whilst the Government frequently claims the change to PIP is not about cutting support for disabled people, they also have clearly stated they hope to save £2billion as a result. It cannot be both.’

6 Comments leave one →
  1. March 10, 2016 9:25 am

    Reblogged this on

  2. Sarah permalink
    March 10, 2016 10:16 am

    It is ridiculous that thousands of us face loosing our independence with the change over from DLA to PIP.
    What freedom does the ability to somehow walk 21 -50 metres make to most disabled people. Few who can walk this distance will have a bus stop sitting waiting to be used, that is if there is even an accessible bus route with the space not taken by parents and pushchairs. Parts of Newcastle have no accessible transport, even if you could reach a pick up point.
    Make certain that if you can walk more than 20m that it is reliably( that you can do it all the tim) timely,( you do not take an extra long time to do it in) repeatedly, and in a safe manor( you do not stagger, loose your balance etc) if you can’t make sure you state this on the assessment form and to any healthcare professional you have contact with.

    We try to be positive about what we can achieve but it usually backfires!

    • March 10, 2016 4:37 pm

      I am so worried that i will loose my mobility scooter, my nearest bus stop is 10 mins walk for the fit and healthy, last time i tried to walk to it took me 25 mins and i was in complete and utter agony, which is why my GP advised me to claim DLA , to be made house bound at the age of 55 how is this fair, my scooter gets me to the park with my little dog, it allows me to do a bit of shopping in the superstore, visit family…i am so worried

    • shaun permalink
      March 11, 2016 11:09 pm

      Being positive about one’s disabilities under this government is positively dangerous to your wealth and health (both mental and physical). In that respect, as numerous others, PIP will turn out to extremely counter-productive. Of course that is what becomes of a society (and for that matter economy, too) that is governed by an elite, which depends on myth and propaganda for its existence.


  1. newshoundsnewsround
  2. David Cameron And Iain Duncan Smith Are Patrons Of The Motability Scheme | Same Difference

What are you thinking?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: