Skip to content

Disabled Lord Criticises ‘Discriminatory’ Attendance Fee Cut

July 2, 2020

A disabled member of the House of Lords has said a cut in the daily fees for peers during the Covid-19 crisis has left him thousands of pounds in debt.

Conservative Lord Shinkwin said a reduction in the allowance from £323 a day to £162 had been “irresponsible and discriminatory”.

He added the cut, in force since early May, had seen his only source of income “slashed without warning”.

A Lords spokesperson said the allowance “was never intended to be a salary”.

The allowance reduction was meant to reflect arrangements which have allowed peers to take part and vote in debates remotely during the pandemic.

The changes were approved by peers after a recommendation from the Lords Commission, which oversees administration of the upper chamber.

At the time, Lord Fowler, the Lord Speaker, said the fees reduction reflected the fact most peers were no longer incurring accommodation costs whilst staying in London.

Most peers are not paid a salary but are able to claim an allowance for the costs associated with attending Parliament.

In a scathing letter to Lord Fowler, Lord Shinkwin said the cut had taken “absolutely no account of the cost of living in the real world”.

The peer, who was born with a rare genetic brittle bone disease, said the move “discriminates against me as a disabled person”, and made the Lords “less diverse and representative”.

The reduction in fees, he added, had left him living off the savings he had accumulated as a “safety net” in case he was not able to work as a peer.

‘I’m alright Jack’

Unlike other peers, he wrote, he did not have the “platinum plated public sector pension” of former MPs, nor a taxpayer-funded housing allowance.

“Such an ‘I’m alright Jack’ approach shows no consideration for those of us who do live in the real world; who gave up secure jobs to enter the Lords in good faith that the allowances would cover our costs,” he added.

Lord Shinkwin called on the Lords Commission to restore the attendance allowance to its former levels at a meeting on Thursday.

‘Difficult decisions’

In response, Lords spokesperson said the Lords Commission recognises the “valuable contribution made by all members who participate in the work of the House.”

They added that “like everyone else, the House of Lords has had to take some difficult decisions because of Covid-19.”

“The Commission has given considerable thought to how to respond to this unprecedented situation, in the full knowledge there are no easy solutions that can satisfy all members’ expectations.

“The daily allowance is not, and was never intended, to be a salary.

“The arrangements are being kept under review as these ways of working evolve.”

2 Comments leave one →
  1. July 2, 2020 12:19 am

    I’m not sure what to say. as a conservative peer, he must have known that his fellow peers and mp’s don’t care for the sick and disable and although he has spent many years in the voluntary sector he still has never managed to prevent their untimely deaths in their hundreds in going through welfare reform.
    as I say I’m not sure what to say. maybe someone else can enlighten me on what this peer has managed to achieve for the sick and disable and vulnerable groups. £162 a day is a darn sight more than what my wife earns at the end of life care working 14 hours a day

  2. July 2, 2020 12:30 am

    I’m not sure what to say. he must have known before he went into the lords as a conservative peer that his fellow conservative peers and conservative mp’s have never cared for the sick and disabled and with many thousands that have died in going through welfare reform he’s not made any inroads to prevent these deaths

    £162 a day is a darn sight more then what my wife earns at the end of life care working 14-hour shifts

    maybe someone can enlighten me on whats he is trying to achieve? whatever it is he hasn’t succeeded in the slightest

    maybe I’m wrong it’s just a bizarre situation that he’s found himself in and the public won’t have any sympathy for him

Leave a Reply to Nick Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: